In anticipation of the discharge of ‘Mank’ on December 4, this week Collider will likely be presenting unique essays and options diving into the work of David Fincher.
Earlier than he began crafting everybody’s favourite status “status popcorn misanthropic thriller options” — and slightly bit throughout, too — David Fincher established his profession directing music movies. His rise within the kind aligned keenly with the rise of the kind itself; Fincher’s first credited music video, Rick Springfield‘s 1984 tune “Dance This World Away”, got here simply three years after MTV’s debut, and you’ll really feel the shortage of abandon and burgeoning experimentation in method all through all his movies, simply as you possibly can really feel popular culture at giant acknowledge the ability and pleasure in aligning visuals to music in such a pure vogue.
Should you’ve not seen any of Fincher’s early music movies, you will discover a few shocking breadcrumbs in these works. One: His knack for immediately iconic imagery is unparalleled. A part of it is because, once more, the type of music movies was so nascent that sure works from sure mammoth artists could not assist however grow to be iconic by happenstance of being “the primary,” however I don’t need this reality to discredit simply how pure, how instinctive, and the way good Fincher is at crafting photographs that stick and linger within the consciousness. And two: There are such robust, straight strains one can draw from Fincher’s impulses within the music video house versus the characteristic movie house, not simply aesthetically, however narratively as nicely; right down to the extent of “one music video seeming to instantly affect or echo in a later movie”.
In celebration of the auteur, we have collected 10 of Fincher’s most notable music movies (one per artist solely) and examined how they reverberate all through the remainder of his profession. And for those who’re into these, there’s many extra so that you can watch, devour, and revel in.
Rick Springfield, “Bop ‘Til You Drop” (1984)
“Within the scorching metropolis / Carry on working day and night time / Do not cease ’til you get what you need”
Straight up, after I watch Fincher’s video for Rick Springfield’s “Bop ‘Til You Drop”, I believe to myself, “Give this man an Alien sequel.” The tune itself provides us enjoyable, soft-pop-rock danceable vitality, however the visible is darkish, drenched in science fiction and horror components, and rife with surreal sensible results. Fincher provides us all of his visible, aesthetic obsessions, particularly in its shadowy compositions, colour palettes alternating between severely gold and grimily heat, and roving, fluid actions. As for his topics? He casts Springfield as one among his many “protagonists who can now not abdomen the informal oppressiveness of the world at giant,” a legendary hero who can save the Sisyphean fates of those poor, pale plebeians pressured to work beneath the monstrous eye of a wild-ass skeletal monster. The best way to win is to “bop till you drop,” sure, however this piece of unusual optimism does not dampen the pure, raw-but-controlled terror lurking inside on this clip’s shadowy frames. A genuinely upsetting, enthralling watch that takes us to Alien 3 rapidly, and makes me need Fincher to attempt one other creature characteristic quickly.
Jermaine Stewart, “We Do not Must Take Our Garments Off” (1986)
“A fast hit, that is your recreation / However I am not a bit of meat, stimulate my mind”
Whereas Mank could be the apotheosis of this impulse, Fincher has been within the language, process, and mythologies behind “traditional Hollywood” since his music movies — doubly so if it is being engaged with by an outsider of the system. You’ll be able to see this from the bounce in “We Do not Must Take Our Garments Off,” that progressive ode to romantic interactions with out sexual stress from Jermaine Stewart (i.e. an outsider from the same old pop music/romance system of “informal intercourse”). We open with a collection of traditional “movie exhibition” title playing cards, counting us down, giving us that temporary upside-down “image begin” intel, reminding me very a lot of Fincher’s meta-textual shenanigans in Struggle Membership. After which Fincher units up a video tableau he’ll return to usually: A gaggle of up to date artists enjoying round with classical Hollywood appears to be like and vibes whereas the proof of their current tense constructions — lights, ladders, cameras, crew — lies round them. We all know from his movies like Zodiac that Fincher loves professionals performing procedures; on this clip, we see how he communicates that impulse merely, rapidly, and solely visually.
Talking of solely visually, Fincher has enjoyable reducing between dramatic compositional lengths, giving us spectacular huge pictures, keenly emotional (even playful, not one thing we see from Fincher usually) close-ups, and an eventual corruption and collusion between the 2 modes. Fincher mucks round with the side ratio to do the whole lot he desires — he is nothing if not a controlling director — till close-ups within the foreground bust open wider side ratios of huge pictures within the background, a wondrous, surprisingly noticeable climax to Fincher’s often invisible dissemination of visible results. Plus, that digicam roves all through the themes, like Fincher’s digicam likes to dang do.
Sting, “Englishman in New York” (1988)
“I am an alien, I am a authorized alien”
It is evident from the track title: Sting‘s “Englishman in New York” is the story of an outsider who can not help however disrupt the system round him. And Fincher merely loves this story, giving it extra “image marker” meta-sound results to intensify it to the purpose of classical filmmaking, discovering the enjoyment within the purity of fusing sound and movement (particularly within the synchronicity of his modifying), blowing up the impulse of “high-contrast colour schemes” to its logical conclusion with such overexposed black-and-white pictures, and naturally, that digicam is at all times roving! There is a purposeful “lack of management” on this clip’s language, although it is clearly managed inside its DNA to look that manner, and it leads to an entirely “alive” feeling clip that provides me some Woman with the Dragon Tattoo vibes, particularly in its backlit tableaus the place we are able to see topics’ breath within the chilly. And in a single spectacularly cacophonous breakdown, the place Sting’s managed, mellow tune erupts in vivid percussion for a few bars, Fincher lets all Hell break free, hinting at a few of the chaotic imagery we’ll ultimately see in Seven‘s opening credit sequence.
Steve Winwood, “Holding On” (1988)
“Folks ought to be looking all night time lengthy / For a cause to assist them dwell”
Whoops, Fincher likes making thrillers! The director takes Steve Winwood‘s “Holding On,” an ode to discovering the one who makes life worthwhile, zeroes in on the desperation and ache evident inside that concept, and blows it out right into a phantasmagoric, intense, explosive examination of the pervasive perversions effervescent beneath essentially the most correct, upper-class denizens of society; it looks like Fincher made The Recreation utilizing solely methods from his Seven title sequence. Once more, Fincher pushes previous the type of “movie,” shifting between each form of colour inventory (black and white, sepia, bleached out colour) and using disruptive flashes of white to invade our house in as subjective a manner as doable (these flashes pleasingly synced up with the music’s hits). As a demo reel for “making a neo-noir,” Fincher has thrown subtlety out the window, exhibiting us all what devilish manufacturing design, oppressive framing methods, and propulsive modifying he can throw on the style if given the prospect. And Winwood himself is our personal eye, our alien observer who keenly observes all of this chaos with out with the ability to do a lot about it; the right protagonist for Fincher’s peerless filmmaking methods.
Paula Abdul, “Straight Up” (1989)
“Misplaced in a dream / I do not know which approach to go”
Within the opening moments of Paula Abdul‘s “Straight Up”, she faucet dances with panache, her and Fincher telling us we will instantly have interaction with classical Hollywood musicals head-on. Then, they’re each like, “Fuck that.” We transfer into a brand new jack swing groove, and a bevy of phenomenal skilled dancers are available to disrupt any earlier myths of Hollywood to breathlessly write a brand new one. And Fincher is right here to movie all of it, pushing his high-contrast lighting-scapes previous the purpose of conventional comprehension, processing the ultimate product in a grimy-yet-glamorous blue-and-white movie inventory that feels timeless and alien. The connection between “motion of topic” and “motion of digicam” continues to be refined and perfected on this clip, with Fincher patiently realizing when he wants to remain nonetheless to let his movers transfer. There’s additionally extra enjoying with “neo-noir” visuals; pictures of Abdul lit brilliantly like a femme fatale cross-cut between a darkly lit, fedora-sporting man in a shadowy cityscape, all heightened by the weird colour correction. And Fincher takes this muckraking with classical visuals to the subsequent degree by interrupting the circulation of the piece with flashes of lyrics onscreen, giving us, once more, Seven titles vibes, straight up.
Aerosmith, “Janie’s Obtained a Gun” (1989)
“They stated when Janie was arrested they discovered him beneath a prepare / However man, he had it comin'”
On Aerosmith‘s “Janie’s Obtained a Gun”, Fincher is flexing. Granted, he was gifted a track that already informed a narrative of psychosexual obsession, upper-class corruptions, and homicide; aka the matters he’d later discover in works like Seven, Gone Woman, The Woman with the Dragon Tattoo, and Mindhunter. However you possibly can really feel Fincher rising to satisfy and exceed the fabric, not content material to easily depict it, leading to one of many purest, most creatively profitable movies of his profession. Janie is an ideal protagonist for Fincher, a younger girl who’s so overwhelmed up and brutalized by her oppressive environment that she is fated to drown in, she should combat again, should resort to a vicious crime in retaliation to the vicious, personal-cum-systemic crimes perpetrated to her. It is all communicated utilizing Fincher’s time-tested methods, crystallized to near-perfect efficacy. Gnarly, shadowy, high-contrast colorscapes make our cities look decrepit and scary, whereas hard-cuts to brightly lit suburban interiors make our “locations of consolation” look unwelcome and alien. The digicam roves and strikes all through each aspect of this oppressive videoscape with management, talent, and motivation. Even the efficiency sequences of Aerosmith enjoying the tune really feel each in dialogue together with his earlier ways of “watching professionals undergo their process with surprisingly huge pictures” and writing new dialogue that aligns one thing as in any other case interesting as “Steven Tyler singing” with an underlit, unsettling milieu. And Fincher additionally weaponizes one of the perversely entertaining meta-aspects of his profession, one thing made textual in moments of Struggle Membership: His must smuggle taboo items of ultra-violence and insanity into mass leisure and tradition. One way or the other, this video about incestual abuse and homicide rife with unsettling imagery grew to become an MTV mainstay, a mere style of issues to come back from Chef Fincher.
Madonna, “Vogue” (1990)
“Go searching, in every single place you flip is heartache / It is in every single place that you simply go”
One of the iconic music movies ever made, from an artist who’s bought fairly a number of of them. Madonna‘s “Vogue” was a game-changer for her, the type of music movies, the extent of dancing acceptable in your common dance flooring (cannot dance? Body your face like a movie shot; carried out), and naturally, for Mr. David Fincher. It is his cleanest tackle “classical Hollywood mythology meets modern muckraking impulses”; Madonna herself borrowed the concept of vogueing from New York Metropolis LGBTQ+ ballroom tradition, fused it with express lyrics and imagery concerning the traditional Hollywood scene (right down to a psuedo-rapped checklist of actors as a bridge), and set all of it to a club-friendly home beat. Fincher took these fusions of tradition, excessive and low, traditional and modern, and got here up with an eminently watchable, entertaining, fashionable, and downright Mank-esque music video.
Like a lot of his earlier video work, we see the detritus of “making a movie” whereas the themes are in the course of “making the movie”. It is in high-contrast, astonishingly lit black-and-white pictures, with Fincher making ample use of shadows and light-weight and the slim areas in between to his benefit. His digicam and modifying instincts are as skilled as they’ve ever been; no transfer or reduce is unmotivated or unmatched to a second of the tune. And in the course of all of it? A narrative a couple of protagonist making an attempt desperately to suit into an oppressive world she does not perceive who resorts to creating her personal guidelines as a response. Strike a pose, change the world.
George Michael, “Freedom! ’90” (1990)
“Properly it appears to be like just like the highway to Heaven / Nevertheless it feels just like the highway to Hell”
In a single performative shot in Panic Room, Fincher’s digicam flows all through Jodie Foster‘s home in a oner, flying via objects’ slim crevasses like they had been nothing, making us really feel like a very fashionable God. Wanna know the place the seeds of that shot had been initially planted? Take a look at the clip for George Michael‘s “Freedom! ’90”, one other ultra-iconic video from an artist chock-full of them. In reality, Michael — and Fincher — have such iconic visuals on their CV that they will have enjoyable of them, placing not simply “traditional Hollywood mythology” via the postmodern blender, however their very own postmodern mythology. “If you shake your ass, they discover quick,” sings Michael, cannily and satirically referencing one of his most famous videos. How does Fincher, so well-known within the business for blowing up and out his topics to vault them into a brand new period of mythology, talk this second? By rapidly, lackadaisically, and snarkily capturing a man carrying boxers from his bottom, not a lot particular in its framing, colour temperature, or modifying rhythm.
“Freedom! ’90”, regardless of its painful lyrics representing the story of an alien man who’s been absorbed by the system solely to search out himself chewed up and spit out, is one among Fincher’s most playful movies. Actually not in kind — we have every kind of completely crafted mini-sequences rife with intentional digicam strikes and rhythmic reducing — however in content material; as an alternative of specializing in one protagonist doing their greatest to outlive, we watch a bunch of regular folks align themselves with this viewpoint, representing one thing I am not used to seeing from Fincher: Optimism. Optimism within the face of anger and ache and self-hatred, certain, however a hard-fought, playful optimism nonetheless. And once we begin to blow up our messed-up previous to attempt for this extra hopeful future, I am unable to assist however consider the self-reflexive narrative gadget in Gone Woman.
As for that Panic Room-esque shot? It occurs rapidly, however is instantly noticeable even in its informal mastery of craft. Fincher’s digicam, which we’re so used to roving all through with ease, passes via the deal with of a tea kettle on its manner towards its topic, a transfer we are going to see always from Fincher all through his characteristic movie profession, Panic Room and in any other case.
A Excellent Circle, “Judith” (2000)
“Oh so some ways for me to point out you / How the savior has deserted you”
By 2000, Fincher had already made his mark as a characteristic filmmaker, giving us Alien 3, Seven, The Recreation, and Struggle Membership, pumping the brakes on his music video profession alongside the way in which. So when he did return to the online game, like in A Excellent Circle‘s “Judith”, it demanded consideration. And “Judith” calls for consideration from starting to finish, regardless of it being one among his less complicated movies in idea and execution. You’ll be able to completely inform this comes from the director of Seven and Struggle Membership, because it’s stuffed with noticeable disruptions, obscuring movie grain, and aggressive corruption of the inventory itself; to not point out its dirty, gritty, sweaty colour temperature and shadowy lighting. It is also in dialogue together with his earlier performance-oriented movies; we see the proof in process of recording the track as they’re recording the track, we see their movement in full show in surprising huge pictures, and we see a merely delicious roving shot via a mixing console.
And, nicely, that is about it! And that is all it must be! By now, Fincher is such a assured stylist, visible storyteller, and understanding of what makes human habits essentially the most compelling to look at, that he solely must shoot a band being a band with corrupted film-stock and intention in development, and will probably be essentially the most fascinating factor you will watch all day.
9 Inch Nails, “Solely” (2005)
“I am much less involved about becoming into the world / Your world, that’s”
After including Panic Room to his characteristic CV, Fincher gave us a style of what his eventual characteristic movie collaborations with Trent Reznor would possibly seem like in the propulsive, minimalist, clinically groovy video for 9 Inch Nails‘ “Solely”. Fincher has taken the CG-aided fluidity in digicam actions taken out for a spin in Struggle Membership and Panic Room and fetishized them to a nearly-absurd diploma, and has determined to fetishize our over reliance on the conveniences, traps, and toys of expertise within the company workspace (one other foreshadowing of Fincher and Reznor’s eventual Social Community magnum opus). Within the clip, Reznor is our alien protagonist who’s been swallowed up by the oppressive world round him. Fairly actually. As in, he solely exists inside a kind of “steel spikes that keep pressed out” workplace toys that represents the banal terrors of company affect so cleanly. However he is not happening with no combat. Over a surprisingly danceable disco-industrial beat, Reznor growls and screams and preens that the oppressive forces that bind him actually don’t exist in his wake; that he’ll destroy any and all shackles in his quest for autonomy; that there isn’t any you, there’s solely me. Whereas Fincher is generally a passive (but bodily very energetic) observer in these proceedings, he ultimately aligns himself with Reznor’s targets, threatening to disrupt the rigorously crafted pablum of this officescape by exploding them with kinetic vitality and rage on the track’s climax, coming this near giving Reznor a contented ending.
However then… Every little thing fades again because it began. The track powers down. And Reznor disappears again into the workplace toy, providing a cynically downbeat epilogue to the “blow up the company buildings” ending supplied by Struggle Membership. However you do not stroll away feeling overwhelmed down. You stroll away feeling impressed, invigorated, able to maintain making an attempt. And you realize that Fincher will likely be prepared to inform tales about folks such as you, making an attempt to combat each system you possibly can with expert-level filmmaking, it doesn’t matter what track underscores it.
Indies, horror films, and even big studio movies that didn’t catch on make up our curated list.
About The Writer