Who Is Holiday? Batman: The Long Halloween Ending Theories Explained

Warning: The next comprises SPOILERS for the graphic novel Batman: The Lengthy Halloween and the movie Batman: The Lengthy Halloween Half One.

Thought of by many to be one of many biggest Batman tales of all time, The Long Halloween relies round a single query: Who Is Vacation, aka The Vacation Killer? The plot of the graphic novel facilities round a sequence of murders focusing on associates of the Godfather of the Gotham Metropolis mobs, Carmine “The Roman” Falcone. Every of the murders takes place on a serious American vacation, resulting in the killer being dubbed Vacation by the native press.

The thriller of Vacation’s identification drives the plot of The Long Halloween, which is the nickname Gotham Metropolis’s underworld offers to the 12 months through which the story takes place. Batman: The Lengthy Halloween Half One takes its story from the primary 4 chapters of the unique 13- half comedian e-book miniseries and particulars 4 particular Vacation killings. The primary occurred on Halloween, focusing on Johnny Viti, Carmine Falcone’s nephew. The second killing, which claimed the lives of the San Ho Hui Triad, occurred on Thanksgiving. The third killing discovered Carmine Falcone’s private bodyguard Milos Grapa shot to demise on Christmas. The ultimate killing, which occurred earlier than Batman and Selina Kyle on New Yr’s Eve, noticed Alberto Falcone, Carmine Falcone’s son, shot within the chest a number of instances earlier than falling over the aspect of his father’s yacht and into the freezing waters of Gotham Metropolis’s bay.

Proceed scrolling to maintain studying
Click on the button beneath to start out this text in fast view.

Associated: What To Expect From Batman: The Long Halloween Part 2

Followers of the unique graphic novel shouldn’t be sure they understand how the animated adaptation will finish with Batman: The Lengthy Halloween Half Two. Warner Bros. Animation have made dramatic modifications in adapting different traditional Batman tales (most notably in the animated version of Batman: Hush) so there’s likelihood the Vacation Killer may be somebody fully completely different than within the e-book. Right here’s a rundown of all the main suspects in Batman: The Lengthy Halloween Half One.

Carmine “The Roman” Falcone

Regardless of a lot of the Vacation killings being directed in the direction of members of the Falcone mob, there’s ample motive to assume that Carmine “The Roman” Falcone might need dedicated the Vacation killings himself as a manner of cleansing up his personal affairs whereas throwing suspicion onto his enemies.  The primary of Vacation’s victims, Johnny Viti, was about to show State’s Proof towards his uncle and was secretly the star witness of Harvey Dent’s case towards Falcone. Equally, Falcone employed the San Ho Hui Triad, who blew up Harvey Dent’s home on Halloween night time. The Triad was killed by Vacation shortly after their chief, Mickey Chen, was questioned by the GCPD.

Whereas Falcone had confirmed himself greater than able to killing and had ample motive to silence Johnny Viti and the San Ho Hui Triad, it made no sense for him to have been concerned with the opposite two Vacation killings. Within the case of the Christmas killing, there was no obvious motive why Falcone would possibly execute his personal bodyguard — a reality that Batman famous particularly. It made even much less sense for him to focus on his personal son, Alberto, on New Yr’s Eve. Past that, the occasions of the film confirmed Vacation making his escape from Falcone’s yacht on an inflatable raft and Falcone was later proven to nonetheless be onboard when the yacht returned to Gotham Harbor and the police started questioning his company.

Salvatore “Sal” Maroni

The second-biggest gangster in Gotham Metropolis and the chief rival of Carmine “The Roman” Falcone, Salvatore “Sal” Maroni had ample motive to see the Falcone household endure and was greater than able to killing in chilly blood. Batman dismissed him as a suspect, nonetheless, saying that whereas Maroni was definitely bold sufficient to make a play towards Falcone, it was extra his model to battle straight. Batman additionally famous that Maroni had already killed a lot of Falcone’s males in broad daylight and that he was unlikely to make the most of the cloak-and-dagger strategies Vacation employed. Past that, it made little sense for Maroni to kill Johnny Viti, who was about to assist Harvey Dent carry down his predominant competitor.

Associated: Batman: The Long Halloween Cast Guide – Every Confirmed Character

Carla Viti

Carmine Falcone’s sister and the top of the Falcone household’s operations in Chicago, Carla Viti was rumored to be making a play to turn out to be the top of the household. Batman believed her to be ruthless sufficient to commit the Vacation killings. Nevertheless, as Alfred Pennyworth identified whereas discussing the case together with his employer, it beggared perception {that a} mom, even a prison one, would start her energy play by killing her personal son on Halloween. Moreover, Carla was by her brother’s aspect when the GCPD had been questioning the company at Falcone’s New Yr’s Eve occasion, which Vacation escaped on a rubber raft. It must also be famous that Vacation gave the impression to be a tall, skinny man, whereas Carla Viti was shorter than common and fairly curvaceous.

The Joker

The Clown Prince of Crime was definitely able to committing the Vacation murders and, not like the opposite suspects Batman thought of, didn’t require any specific motive for carrying them out. Nevertheless, it’s dramatically out of character for The Joker to not take credit score for a profitable crime as soon as he has dedicated it — and the Joker is a notorious killer, so it doesn’t make sense for him to undertake one other identification to kill individuals in secret. The Joker himself provided the perfect argument for his innocence when he identified to Batman, who accused The Joker of being Vacation whereas he was in the course of his personal New Yr’s Eve homicide spree, “If I had been him, why would I be making an attempt to kill him?” Moreover, Joker was presumably nonetheless in police custody on the time of the fourth Vacation killing on New Years Eve, having been subdued by Batman earlier within the night.

Harvey Dent

The fifth and ultimate suspect Batman thought of (whereas admitting he didn’t need to take into account him) was District Attorney Harvey Dent, who was obsessive about taking down Carmine Falcone at any price. The DA even admitted to Batman in personal that he was pondering how straightforward it will be to cross all of the traces that separated them from the dangerous guys. Batman additionally found that Dent had utilized for a gun license the earlier 12 months, however had been rejected after his necessary psychiatric analysis discovered some “wild aberrations.”  Dent additionally matches the bodily profile of the Vacation Killer and was not among the many company of Carmine Falcone’s New Yr’s Eve occasion. Nevertheless, it makes little sense for Dent to have kicked off Vacation’s reign of terror by killing his personal star witness, Johnny Viti.

Alberto Falcone

Alberto Falcone turned Batman’s prime suspect within the climax of Batman: The Long Halloween Part One. Batman theorized that Alberto, who had been despatched off to review enterprise at Oxford however by no means introduced in to handle the household affairs, had grown resentful of his standing as “the nice son” and began killing off his father’s allies in a bid to take over the Falcone household. Nevertheless, as Alberto had informed Selina Kyle earlier on New Yr’s Eve, he had no real interest in his household’s cash or energy and would gladly have given up any connection to the Falcone title for an opportunity at a standard life. Nevertheless, Alberto had apparently misplaced the one lady who ever liked him due to his father’s efforts to regulate each side of his life, giving him one more reason to need to damage his father’s enterprise affairs as Vacation.

Whereas Alberto was apparently the fourth Vacation sufferer in Batman: The Lengthy Halloween Half One, it needs to be famous that his physique was nonetheless being looked for within the movie’s closing moments. The unique graphic novel featured a twist that exposed that there have been two Vacation killers, with it being urged that Alberto Falcone had dedicated the primary three killings earlier than being shot by a second occasion and faking his demise, with the second Vacation happening to commit the remainder of the killings. This might be modified for the movie adaptation, however in any case, Batman can have his arms full unraveling the thriller of The Long Halloween.

Extra: Batman: The Long Halloween Post-Credits Scene & Sequel Setup Explained

Why Suicide Squad 2 Removes Harley Quinn’s “Rotten” Tattoo

About The Creator